Home
|
Meetings
|
Local Sites
|
Contact Us
|
How To Join
|
Forum
Welcome, Guest. Please
Login
.
Sep 5
th
, 2010, 5:44am
News:
Please
Contact the Webmaster
today to join
Huddersfield Birdwatchers Club Forum
›
Public Categories
›
Bird ID Help
(Moderator:
YaBB Administrator
)
‹
Previous topic
|
Next topic
›
Pages: 1
Whitethroat and Lesser Whitethroat (Read 352 times)
philmcgenity
YaBB Newbies
I Love YaBB 2!
Posts: 6
Whitethroat and Lesser Whitethroat
Apr 25
th
, 2010, 10:09am
Seeing that the first few reports of these two birds for tyhis year are now appearing on the forum, I'd like to ask for any hints about separating these two species. I'm aware of some differences in the song (I have recordings of both), but I'm not very clear if there's anything visual which can be picked up readily. Any thoughts from seasoned observers will be gratefully received.
Back to top
IP Logged
ShelleyNaturalist
Senior Member
Posts: 264
Re: Whitethroat and Lesser Whitethroat
Reply #1 -
Apr 25
th
, 2010, 12:05pm
Firstly, try to learn the songs, once you have picked up a Lessers final rattle, which is far-carrying, (The start of their song can only be heard at close range), it is unmistakeable apart from perhaps Cirl Bunting which should not be an issue around here! The calls are similar but can be separated with practice.
Lessers are notorious skulkers, look for them in thick, tall, unkempt hedgerows and bushes and scrub. They tend to move about a lot amongst the bushes and can be difficult to see or approach.
Generally, Common Whitethroats are more obvious and do have a song display flight. They will tend to come out of hiding and have a look at you before diving back into scrub especially Brambles. They will then spend time scolding you with a hard call until you move away.
Lessers always look cold and grey, whereas Commons are quite rufous particularly in the wings and when freshly arrived. Juvenile Lessers are particularly attractive with a black bandit mask, resembling a small shrike briefly.
Hope this helps,
Steve
Back to top
IP Logged
philmcgenity
YaBB Newbies
I Love YaBB 2!
Posts: 6
Re: Whitethroat and Lesser Whitethroat
Reply #2 -
Apr 25
th
, 2010, 3:25pm
Many thanks, Steve
Back to top
IP Logged
MickCunningham
Senior Member
I Love YaBB 2!
Posts: 254
Re: Whitethroat and Lesser Whitethroat
Reply #3 -
Apr 25
th
, 2010, 7:14pm
Hi Phil
have you got the Collin's guide? it's all in there mate!
I have a v battered copy of first edition (courtesy airliners)you can have free if you want.
the new paperback edition is only about 15 quid
Back to top
IP Logged
philmcgenity
YaBB Newbies
I Love YaBB 2!
Posts: 6
Re: Whitethroat and Lesser Whitethroat
Reply #4 -
Apr 25
th
, 2010, 9:43pm
Good point Mick - no, I don't have a copy of Collins, but have just ordered one from Amazon.
Back to top
IP Logged
MickCunningham
Senior Member
I Love YaBB 2!
Posts: 254
Re: Whitethroat and Lesser Whitethroat
Reply #5 -
Apr 29
th
, 2010, 11:18pm
it will be an eye-opener. A superb distillation of the (mostly) best ID features known, tho the Scandinavian influence on call descriptions means these read oddly to English speakers.
What a change from when I started when many many plates just didn't depict what the birds looked like in life and descriptions were trite, or relied on features that were too hard to see in the field or not diagnostic. Jonsson was an eye-opener but the real breakthru was the MaCmillan guide. Until then the real secrets were in journals and expensive specialist monographs.
and then came Collins - bow down and worship.
btw - I was able to ID more birds once i really learned bird topography! if you can ever get hold of an out of print pamphlet 'The New Approach to Identification' by Grant and Mullarney buy it - it is a brilliant summation of topography and moult
for use in the field
still loads of birds I can't ID tho
Back to top
IP Logged
MickCunningham
Senior Member
I Love YaBB 2!
Posts: 254
Re: Whitethroat and Lesser Whitethroat
Reply #6 -
Jun 14
th
, 2010, 4:16pm
hi phil
did the book sort out them whitethroats?
Back to top
IP Logged
Pages: 1
Huddersfield Birdwatchers Club Forum
›
Public Categories
›
Bird ID Help
(Moderator:
YaBB Administrator
)
‹
Previous topic
|
Next topic
›
Forum Jump:
-----------------------------
Public Categories
-----------------------------
- Local Sightings
- Gallery
- Club News & Events
=> Bird ID Help
- Bird Chat
- Off Topic Chat
-----------------------------
Member Only Categories
-----------------------------
- Forum Q&A
Huddersfield Birdwatchers Club Forum
» Powered by
YaBB 2.1
!
YaBB
© 2000-2005. All Rights Reserved.
Copyright Reserved 2006 Huddersfield Birdwatchers’ Club Registered Charity No 1098296